Claim: COVID‑19 vaccines increase the risk of toxic encephalopathy by 157 times compared with flu shots
0%- The “157×” figure originates from a retrospective VAERS study (Cosgrove et al., 2025) that reports an odds ratio of 157 for toxic encephalopathy when comparing COVID-19 vaccine adverse-event reports to influenza vaccine reports1. The study’s methods state that these are odds ratios (ORs) derived from passive surveillance data, not measures of incidence or risk1.
- The U.S. Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) is a passive, voluntary database that the CDC and FDA explicitly say cannot be used to assess incidence rates, establish causality, or directly compare risk between different vaccines2.
- The 157 value is a disproportionality metric (reporting odds ratio), not a risk ratio; it reflects the relative proportion of a specific event among all submitted reports, not the actual probability of developing toxic encephalopathy34.
- Presenting this reporting odds ratio as a proven 157-fold increase in “risk” is a well-documented misinterpretation of VAERS data34.
- Large population-based studies contradict the claimed risk elevation: a primary-care cohort study found a standardized incidence ratio of 0.79 for encephalitis after the BNT162b2 vaccine—below the expected background rate—and overall post-vaccination encephalitis incidence is estimated at roughly 1.9 cases per million doses3.
- No credible, peer-reviewed epidemiological study has demonstrated a 157-fold increase in the actual risk of toxic encephalopathy from COVID-19 vaccines.
Overall validity: 0%